The Federal Court of Appeal overturned the Federal Court’s decision requiring the production of documents in the hands of a government institution on the basis that the Federal Court refused to hear evidence regarding the government institution’s late assertion of a mandatory exemption for the production of the requested records. The Federal Court of Appeal ...
Newfoundland Court of Appeal held that parents were entitled to make representations to a properly constituted school board with respect to decision about the closure of an elementary school. Administrative law – Decisions of administrative tribunals – School boards – Schools – Powers and duties – Parental rights – Judicial review – Appeals Young v. Newfoundland and Labrador English School District, [2017] N.J. ...
Edmond deals with the issue of when, and under what circumstances, a delay in the administrative process will warrant an order granting a stay of proceedings. Administrative law – Decisions of administrative tribunals – Securities Commission – Jurisdiction – Judicial review – Stay of proceedings – Delay – Appeals – Standard of review New Brunswick (Financial and Consumer Services Commission) v. Edmond, [2017] N.B.J. ...
Appeal by Brookfield from the dismissal of its appeal from an arbitrator’s decision, setting the fair market rent payable to the City of Toronto pursuant to a ground lease. Administrative law – Arbitration and award – Judicial review – Natural justice – Appeals – Evidence – Landlord and tenant 6524443 Canada Inc. v. Toronto (City), [2017] ...
International medical graduate was dismissed from his anesthesia residency program following his failure to satisfy the requirements of his third remediation/probation plan. The dismissal was upheld on appeal and by the Court on judicial review. Administrative law – Decisions of administrative tribunals – Academic Appeals Committee – Professions – Physicians and surgeons – Competence – ...
An application for judicial review was struck because it was served outside the six-month limitation period. The court held it did not have jurisdiction to extend the deadline for service. Administrative Law – Appeals – Judicial Review – Jurisdiction – Limitations Baker v. Drouin, [2017] A.J. N o. 329, 2017 ABQB 204, Alberta Court of ...
The applicant is a police officer with the Amherstburg Police Service. The respondent made a complaint to the Office of the Independent Policy Review Director (“OIPRD”) as a result of a confrontation he had with the applicant when he was pulled over. As a result of the confrontation, the respondent was charged with assaulting a ...
Appellate court affirms Tribunal’s decision that injuries caused to members of a CEO advisory group did not arise out of and in the course of their employment. Administrative law – Appeals – Decisions of administrative tribunals – Evidence – In and out of the course of employment – Judicial Review – Patent unreasonableness – Policies ...
When a tribunal is granted a high degree of deference it may not be patently unreasonable for the tribunal to dismiss an appeal of its decision without a hearing. Administrative law – Appeals – Bias – Decisions of administrative tribunals – Employment law – Employment Standards Tribunal – Evidence – Hearings – Judicial Review – ...
Administrative law – Judicial review – Administrative decisions – Arbitration and award – Unreasonableness – Appeals – Standard of review – Correctness – Reasonableness simpliciter – Evidence Intact insurance Co. v. Allstate Insurance Co. of Canada, [2016] O.J. No. 4113, 2016 ONCA 609, Ontario Court of Appeal, August 4, 2016, R.J. Sharpe, H.S. LaForme and ...